Personal tools

Home > The Cases > Arvin McGee

Arvin McGee

Arvin McGee

13 Years in Prison: Innocent

Cause: Eyewitness Misidentification
Real Perpetrator Found: Yes
State: Oklahoma
Arvin McGee
Share This:

Photo by Michael Wyke, Tulsa World 


In 1987, a twenty-year-old woman was attacked in the Tulsa, Oklahoma, laundry where she worked. The victim was tied up and locked in the restroom. The attacker returned, carried her over his shoulders to a car, drove to a secluded area, and raped her. In 1989, after three trials, Arvin Carsell McGee was convicted of this brutal crime and sentenced to 365 years in prison.

McGee's conviction rested largely on the victim's identification. McGee was identified from a photographic array four months after the crime occurred. She had initially picked out another man in another photographic lineup. Prosecutors also relied on serological testing of semen collected from the victim, which could not exclude McGee as a possible contributor.

McGee continued to maintain his innocence. At the time of the crime, he was suffering from an injury requiring surgery, rendering him physically unable to carry out the crime. His defense attorneys also pointed out the inconsistencies in the victim's description of her attacker, which changed several times. McGee's first trial was a mistrial, the second ended in a hung jury. After the third trial, he was convicted of rape, kidnapping, forcible sodomy, and robbery. His sentence was later reduced to 298 years.

More than thirteen years later, his case was taken on by the Oklahoma Indigent Defense System. They arranged for DNA testing of the semen evidence. The results revealed that McGee was excluded as a contributor of the spermatozoa and, therefore, could not have been the perpetrator. A second round of testing ordered by Tulsa County prosecutors yielded the same results. Arvin McGee was exonerated and freed from prison in February 2002. He had spent more than 12 years in prison for a crime he did not commit.

In September 2002, Oklahoma authorities revealed that the DNA profile from the spermatozoa evidence matched the profile of Edward Alberty, a prisoner in Oklahoma. Alberty has since been charged with first degree rape and forcible sodomy.

How is Oklahoma doing?

US Question Map

The Causes

  • Eyewitness Misidentification
> View All Causes

The Facts

Incident Date: 10/29/87
Jurisdiction: OK
Charge: Rape, Kidnapping, Robbery, Forcible Sodomy
Conviction: Rape, Kidnapping, Robbery, Forcible Sodomy
Conviction Date: 6/22/89
Exoneration Date: 2/26/02
Sentence: 365 years
Served: 13 years
Real Perpetrator Found: Yes
Compensation: Civil Suit
Recent Cases

Floyd Bledsoe

15 years. Innocent.

Donovan Allen

years. Innocent.

Ronjon Cameron

12 years. Innocent.

Luis Vargas

16 years. Innocent.

> View All Cases
Join the Movement

Join the nearly 50,000 people who are committed to helping free the innocent.